Room spell experience split bug

[Greater]

Giant Fortress, Animal Pen
Also here: Katniss, giant war dog, giant war dog, giant war dog, giant war dog,
giant war dog, giant war dog, giant war dog, giant war dog, giant war dog,
giant war dog, angry hill giant shaman, giant war dog, giant war dog, fat hill
giant.
Obvious exits: south, east, open gate west, northeast
[HP=634/MA=461]:par
The giant war dog snaps at Katniss with its teeth!
The giant war dog snaps at Katniss, but she dodges out of the way!
The giant war dog hits Katniss, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog snaps at you with its teeth!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog snaps at you with its teeth!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog viciously bites you for 5 damage!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog snaps at you with its teeth!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog snaps at you with its teeth!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog snaps at you with its teeth!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The angry hill giant shaman swipes at Katniss with their giantwood club!
The angry hill giant shaman smashes Katniss for 20 damage!
The angry hill giant shaman swipes at Katniss with their giantwood club!
The angry hill giant shaman clobbers Katniss, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog snaps at Katniss with its teeth!
The giant war dog mauls Katniss for 4 damage!
The giant war dog hits Katniss, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog snaps at you with its teeth!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The giant war dog hits you, but the swing glances off!
The fat hill giant smashes Katniss for 26 damage!
The fat hill giant swipes at Katniss with their giantwood club!
The fat hill giant swipes at Katniss with their giantwood club!
You hear movement to the west.
You hear movement to the west.
You hear movement to the west.
You hear movement to the west.
The following people are in your travel party:
  Dogeness Evergreen            (Druid)      [M:100%] [H: 98%]   - Frontrank
  Katniss Everdeen              (Druid)      [M: 65%] [H: 88%]   - Backrank
[HP=635/MA=461]:atem
*Combat Engaged*
A hill giant shaman stomps into the room!
A giant war dog enters the room from west.
A giant war dog enters the room from west.
Katniss moves to attack everyone in the room.
[HP=641/MA=461]:break
*Combat Off*
[HP=641/MA=461]:
Giant Fortress, Animal Pen
Also here: Katniss, giant war dog, giant war dog, giant war dog, giant war dog,
giant war dog, giant war dog, giant war dog, giant war dog, giant war dog,
giant war dog, angry hill giant shaman, giant war dog, giant war dog, fat hill
giant, nasty hill giant shaman, giant war dog, giant war dog.
Obvious exits: south, east, open gate west, northeast
Katniss makes a sharp gesture!
An earthquake rocks the room for 329 damage!
The giant war dog lets out a yelp and dies!
You gain 900 experience.
Katniss makes a sharp gesture!
An earthquake rocks the room for 329 damage!
The giant war dog lets out a yelp and dies!
You gain 900 experience.
Katniss makes a sharp gesture!
An earthquake rocks the room for 329 damage!
The giant war dog lets out a yelp and dies!
You gain 900 experience.
Katniss makes a sharp gesture!
An earthquake rocks the room for 329 damage!
The giant war dog lets out a yelp and dies!
You gain 900 experience.
Katniss makes a sharp gesture!
An earthquake rocks the room for 329 damage!
The giant war dog lets out a yelp and dies!
You gain 900 experience.
Katniss makes a sharp gesture!
An earthquake rocks the room for 329 damage!
The giant war dog lets out a yelp and dies!
You gain 900 experience.
Katniss makes a sharp gesture!
An earthquake rocks the room for 329 damage!
The giant war dog lets out a yelp and dies!
You gain 900 experience.
Katniss makes a sharp gesture!
An earthquake rocks the room for 329 damage!
The giant war dog lets out a yelp and dies!
You gain 900 experience.
Katniss makes a sharp gesture!
An earthquake rocks the room for 329 damage!
The giant war dog lets out a yelp and dies!
You gain 900 experience.
Katniss makes a sharp gesture!
An earthquake rocks the room for 329 damage!
The giant war dog lets out a yelp and dies!
You gain 900 experience.
Katniss makes a sharp gesture!
An earthquake rocks the room for 329 damage!
The giant war dog lets out a yelp and dies!
You gain 900 experience.
The giant war dog lets out a yelp and dies!
You gain 900 experience.
The giant war dog lets out a yelp and dies!
You gain 900 experience.
The giant war dog lets out a yelp and dies!
You gain 900 experience.
angry hill giant shaman attempts to cast splinterstorm on Katniss, but fails.
The fat hill giant swipes at Katniss with their giantwood club!
The fat hill giant swipes at Katniss with their giantwood club!
The fat hill giant swipes at Katniss with their giantwood club!
The nasty hill giant shaman swipes at Katniss with their giantwood club!
The nasty hill giant shaman swipes at Katniss with their giantwood club!
The nasty hill giant shaman smashes Katniss for 12 damage!
A hill giant stomps into the room!
[HP=645/MA=461]:
Giant Fortress, Animal Pen
Also here: Katniss, angry hill giant shaman, fat hill giant, nasty hill giant
shaman, thin hill giant.
Obvious exits: south, east, open gate west, northeast
[HP=645/MA=461]:atem
*Combat Engaged*
[HP=645/MA=461]:break
Katniss breaks off combat.
Katniss moves to attack everyone in the room.
*Combat Off*
The angry hill giant shaman smashes Katniss for 8 damage!
The fat hill giant swipes at Katniss with their giantwood club!
The fat hill giant smashes Katniss for 18 damage!
The fat hill giant smashes Katniss for 7 damage!
nasty hill giant shaman attempts to cast splinterstorm on you, but fails.
The thin hill giant smashes you for 9 damage!
The thin hill giant slams you, but the swing glances off!
The thin hill giant smashes you for 22 damage!
Katniss makes a sharp gesture!
An earthquake rocks the room for 199 damage!
The hill giant shaman lets out a yell and falls lifeless.
You gain 3250 experience.
Katniss makes a sharp gesture!
An earthquake rocks the room for 199 damage!
The hill giant falls to the ground with a crash and dies!
You gain 3000 experience.
Katniss makes a sharp gesture!
An earthquake rocks the room for 199 damage!
The hill giant shaman lets out a yell and falls lifeless.
You gain 3250 experience.
Katniss makes a sharp gesture!
An earthquake rocks the room for 199 damage!
Katniss telepaths: @wait (HP's too low)
Katniss begins to chant in arcane tones.
Katniss completes the regeneration spell, and lays hands upon Katniss!
Katniss telepaths: @ok
[HP=614/MA=461]:
Giant Fortress, Animal Pen
You notice 11 gold crowns, 56 silver nobles here.
Also here: Katniss, thin hill giant.
Obvious exits: south, east, open gate west, northeast
[HP=614/MA=461]:atem
*Combat Engaged*
[HP=614/MA=461]:break
Katniss moves to attack everyone in the room.
*Combat Off*
The thin hill giant swipes at Katniss with their giantwood club!
The thin hill giant swipes at Katniss with their giantwood club!
The thin hill giant smashes Katniss for 33 damage!
Katniss makes a sharp gesture!
An earthquake rocks the room for 207 damage!
The hill giant falls to the ground with a crash and dies!
You gain 3000 experience.

Pretty self explanatory. I stole half of Katniss's experience from rooming without casting a single room spell.

[Vitoc]

I believe it's supposed to work this way.

It's the same as combat.  As long as you have combat engaged, it doesn't matter if you actually swing or not if the mob dies or is killed from someone else; you get the exp.

[Greater]

I believe it's supposed to work this way.

It's the same as combat.  As long as you have combat engaged, it doesn't matter if you actually swing or not if the mob dies or is killed from someone else; you get the exp.

Look again. I wasn't engaged for any of that exp. At all.

[Hurricane Omega]

It is one thing if you are actively engaged in combat, but he broke combat and still got experience for it.  That doesn't happen for melee combat.

[Crabster]

[HP=645/MA=461]:break
Katniss breaks off combat.

[Vile]

This is definitely buggy.

I quak in a room with a hoardling + loth. Once the hoardling dies my combat is off and trying to quak again gives "Your spell has no effect in this room!" but I receive exp when loth dies.

Hydroponic moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
KillerBee moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
Hydroponic moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
Shet moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
Hydroponic moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
Woke hurls their chakram and strikes Lord of the Hunt for 30 damage!
Woke hurls their chakram and strikes Lord of the Hunt for 18 damage!
Woke hurls their chakram and strikes Lord of the Hunt for 16 damage!
Woke hurls their chakram and strikes Lord of the Hunt for 34 damage!
Woke critically hurls their chakram and strikes Lord of the Hunt for 121 damage!
Woke hurls their chakram and strikes Lord of the Hunt for 26 damage!
Hydroponic slices Lord of the Hunt for 26 damage!
Hydroponic rips Lord of the Hunt for 25 damage!
Hydroponic slices Lord of the Hunt for 21 damage!
Lightning strikes Lord of the Hunt for lightning hits damage!
Hydroponic critically slashes Lord of the Hunt for 69 damage!
Hydroponic slashes Lord of the Hunt for 17 damage!
Lightning strikes Lord of the Hunt for lightning hits damage!
KillerBee chops Lord of the Hunt for 48 damage!
KillerBee chops Lord of the Hunt for 110 damage!
KillerBee swings at at Lord of the Hunt, but he dodges out of the way!
Shet clobbers Lord of the Hunt for 129 damage!
You make a sharp gesture!
An earthquake rocks the room for 152 damage!
The hordeling screeches violently!
The hordeling explodes in a spray of venom!
You gain 4000 experience.
*Combat Off*
Lord of the Hunt uses their spear and skewers Woke for 121 damage!
Shet casts major healing on you!
Shet moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
KillerBee casts mend on you, regenerating some of your wounds!
Shet moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
KillerBee moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
KillerBee moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
Shet moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
Shet moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
Hydroponic casts major healing rain on you, healing 35 damage!
Hydroponic moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
Shet moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
Woke hurls their chakram and strikes Lord of the Hunt for 14 damage!
Woke misses at Lord of the Hunt, but he dodges out of the way!
Woke hurls their chakram and strikes Lord of the Hunt for 43 damage!
Woke misses at Lord of the Hunt, but he dodges out of the way!
Woke hurls their chakram and strikes Lord of the Hunt for 21 damage!
Woke hurls their chakram and strikes Lord of the Hunt for 16 damage!
Hydroponic critically rips Lord of the Hunt for 117 damage!
Hydroponic rips Lord of the Hunt for 11 damage!
Hydroponic swings at at Lord of the Hunt, but he dodges out of the way!
Hydroponic slashes Lord of the Hunt for 9 damage!
Lightning strikes Lord of the Hunt for lightning hits damage!
Hydroponic slashes Lord of the Hunt for 20 damage!
Lightning strikes Lord of the Hunt for lightning hits damage!
KillerBee hacks Lord of the Hunt for 103 damage!
KillerBee swings at at Lord of the Hunt, but he dodges out of the way!
KillerBee hacks Lord of the Hunt for 103 damage!
Shet swipes at at Lord of the Hunt, but he dodges out of the way!
The Lord of the Hunt impales Torque for 57 damage!
Energy sears Torque for energy hits damage!
The Lord of the Hunt lunges at Torque with their nexus spear!
The Lord of the Hunt hurls his nexus spear at Torque for 65 damage!
Energy sears Torque for energy hits damage!
KillerBee moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
Shet moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
[HP=272/MA=160]:quak
Your spell has no effect in this room!
Torque sings the song of life to you!
You are healing faster!
Torque stops to rest.
Torque says "@heal"
[HP=279/MA=175]:quak
Your spell has no effect in this room!
Hydroponic moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
KillerBee moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
Shet moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
[HP=279/MA=175]:
Black Wasteland
You notice whirling vortex here.
Also here: Woke, Hydroponic, KillerBee, Shet, Torque, Lord of the Hunt.
Obvious exits: north, south, west, northwest, southeast
[HP=279/MA=175]:.aw
You say "aw"
Woke hurls their chakram and strikes Lord of the Hunt for 38 damage!
Woke misses at Lord of the Hunt, but he dodges out of the way!
Woke hurls their chakram and strikes Lord of the Hunt for 26 damage!
Woke hurls their chakram and strikes Lord of the Hunt for 28 damage!
Woke hurls their chakram and strikes Lord of the Hunt for 20 damage!
Woke hurls their chakram and strikes Lord of the Hunt for 25 damage!
Hydroponic swings at at Lord of the Hunt, but he dodges out of the way!
Hydroponic rips Lord of the Hunt for 17 damage!
Hydroponic slices Lord of the Hunt for 8 damage!
Hydroponic critically slashes Lord of the Hunt for 72 damage!
Hydroponic slices Lord of the Hunt for 12 damage!
KillerBee chops Lord of the Hunt for 50 damage!
KillerBee lacerates Lord of the Hunt wide open and their blood gushes forth!
KillerBee hacks Lord of the Hunt for 120 damage!
KillerBee lacerates Lord of the Hunt wide open and their blood gushes forth!
KillerBee chops Lord of the Hunt for 102 damage!
Shet swipes at at Lord of the Hunt, but he dodges out of the way!
The Lord of the Hunt impales Shet for 15 damage!
Energy sears Shet for energy hits damage!
The Lord of the Hunt impales Shet for 54 damage!
Energy sears Shet for energy hits damage!
KillerBee casts mend on Torque!
KillerBee moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
KillerBee moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
Hydroponic casts major healing rain on you, healing 28 damage!
Hydroponic moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
Hydroponic moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
Shet casts major healing on Shet!
Torque stops to rest.
Shet moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
[HP=307/MA=175]:l lord
Please be more specific.  You could have meant any of these:
-- Lord of the Hunt
-- head of the woodelf lord
[HP=307/MA=175]:par
You are following Woke.
The following people are in your travel party:
  Woke Smeed                    (Ninja)               [H: 81%]   - Frontrank
  Hydroponic                    (Missionary) [M: 85%] [H:100%]   - Frontrank
  KillerBee Killed              (Ranger)     [M: 87%] [H:100%]   - Frontrank
  Shet                          (Cleric)     [M: 97%] [H: 80%]   - Frontrank
  Torque                        (Bard)       [M: 79%] [H: 64%] R - Frontrank
  Vile                          (Druid)      [M: 62%] [H: 84%]   - Backrank
KillerBee moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
Shet moves to attack Lord of the Hunt.
The Lord of the Hunt impales Shet for 72 damage!
Energy sears Shet for energy hits damage!
The Lord of the Hunt all-out skewers Shet for 206 damage!
The Lord of the Hunt hurls his nexus spear at Shet for 31 damage!
Energy sears Shet for energy hits damage!
The Lord of the Hunt impales Shet for 58 damage!
Energy sears Shet for energy hits damage!
Shet drops to the ground!
Woke critically hurls their chakram and strikes Lord of the Hunt for 164 damage!
Woke critically hurls their chakram and strikes Lord of the Hunt for 96 damage!
The Lord of the Hunt laughs contemptuously, and vanishes in a flash!
You gain 1250000 experience.

[Zetetic]

Earthquake is level 28, LotH is spell immune +35, hence why quak no longer works. However, you shouldn't have gotten the exp for killing LotH as you shouldn't have been able to stay engaged in combat.

[Vile]

Earthquake is level 28, LotH is spell immune +35, hence why quak no longer works. However, you shouldn't have gotten the exp for killing LotH as you shouldn't have been able to stay engaged in combat.

I wasn't engaged in combat, but still got exp.

[Zetetic]

My assumption is that Greatermud thought you were still engaged in combat as there was still a monster in the room when the previous monster died. You couldn't attempt to attack again using the spell as there was no valid target, but I would lay a bet that if you had manually broken combat at that point, you would have received a *Combat Off* message and then not gotten the exp from LotH.

[mad]

I guess when you cast a room spell you've tagged that monster until it dies and there's no *Combat Off* on the other end, not that they see it. Also may seem, let's look at the loth kill,

Not sure if the QUAK actually damaged LOTH, but my guess is that if there are mobs that can take the room spell, the room takes the spell, until you can no longer cast it; ie you can quak loth until the adds are gone.

More bugs ..

[Hurricane Omega]

In the opening post, he breaks off combat and gets the "combat off" message, but still gets credit for the kills.

[HP=641/MA=461]:break
*Combat Off*

[mad]

I think we're looking at two issues causing the same symptom (getting XP)

1. casting a room spell and hitting mobs you shouldnt be due to level requirements, AKA loth
2. breaking after tagging monsters with a room spell and gaining XP (what happens if you leave the room?? worth a test)